Special Report: The Kosovo Liberation Army in
Transition: Post-War Rivalries
Defense & Foreign Affairs Special Analysis - March 29, 2007, Thursday
Note: Where applicable, Serbo-Croat accents have been used in location and
personal names. They may not appear on all computers.
Analysis. By Sla ana uri , in Belgrade.* Research into any issue in Kosovo and
Metohija today is an enormous challenge, as well as a problem.
There are almost no objective indicators of any aspect of social life. Moreover,
any serious academic effort to explain an issue is overshadowed by the
impossibility of direct access of researchers, and traditional unapproachability
of both Albanian community and relevant international community institutions.
Those formal problems are additionally aggravated by the ever-present, and now
very emphasized, possibility of having the obtained findings labeled as
"non-scientific", "biased", "malicious", etc.
Nevertheless, the relevancy of the need for more detailed insight into and
knowledge of developments in the territory of this region at the time of
intensification of negotiations on its status constitutes our motive for at
least attempting to create an overview of the dominant courses of security
conditions in the post-war period as well as a review of the activities of the
network of legal and illegal security structures.
Data used in this paper come from regular "Reports on the Situation in Kosovo"
by the US Mission in Pristina,<1> relevant documents and reports by the UNMIK
police,<2> KFOR,<3> OSCE,<4> periodic reports by the International Crisis
Group,<5> UNDP in Kosovo (United Nations Development Program in Kosovo)
analyses,<6> analysis by the Institute for War & Peace reporting (IWPR),<7>
analysis by the Balkan Investigative Reporting Network (BIRN),<8> field
investigations by the author in the Kosovo and Metohija area in 2000-2006
period, as well as a series of interviews with Albanian and international
officials.
Kosovo and Metohija, the Political Context
Kosovo and Metohija has been an entity under interim international
administration for seven years. This southern Serbian province, covering the
territory of approximately 10,849 km<2> and having a population of some
two-million, became an area of intense interest for politicians, military
strategists, intelligence services, and media several years ago.
A powerful conflict of interests which had existed in this area for several
decades between the aspirations of the Albanian population for secession and
formation of an independent state, and our state, striving to preserve the
territorial integrity, culminated in 1999. Namely, it was then that the
international community appraised that the state administration of Serbia had
overstepped its authority in applying excessive force, which had resulted in
ethnic cleansing against the Albanian population in the province.
The response to such an appraisal was the NATO air campaign against FRY in the
March 24-June 9, 1999, period. The end of the intervention was followed by
intensive restructuring of life in Kosovo and Metohija, where administration of
Interim Administrative UN Mission in Kosovo was established (UNMIK) pursuant to
the Resolution 1244 of the UN Security Council ( uri , 2005).
Pursuant to the Resolution 1244 of the UN Security Council, Kosovo is under the
civil administration of Interim Administrative UN Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK).
UNMIK passes regulations related to civil and legal obligations of government
bodies and private persons, and ratifies laws passed by the Kosovo Parliament.
UNMIK has published the Constitutional Framework for Provisional Self-Government
of Kosovo (Constitutional Framework), which defines Provisional Institutions of
Self-Government (PISG: Assembly, Kosovo President, government, judiciary, local
self-government institutions).
Kosovo has a multiparty system, dominated by four practically mono-ethnic
Albanian parties. There are also several ethnic minority parties and coalitions.
In the last parliamentary elections, held in October 2004, the Democratic League
of Kosovo (Lidhja Demokratike e Kosoves : LDK) proved to be still the most
popular political party in Kosovo (45.4 percent votes won), but failed to obtain
sufficient majority to be able to form a central government on its own. LDK
formed a ruling coalition with AAK (8.4 percent), led by Ramush Haradinaj (the
Hague arrestee for a time, accused of war crimes), and with the parliamentary
Six Plus group, which is a coalition of Turkish and Bosniak parties.
The leading opposition political parties are PDK (28.9 percent), led by Hashim
Thaqi (also transliterated as "Thaci"), and Reform Party ORA (6.2 percent), led
by Veton Surroi.
The last elections in the Province were almost completely boycotted by Serb
voters, so the two Serb parties in Kosovo got only the 10 parliamentary seats
guaranteed by the Constitutional Framework. The very fact that a coalition
government was created between the erstwhile bitter foes - LDK and AAK - "was
one of the strangest political combinations Kosovo had seen since the end of the
armed conflict" (Qirezi, 2004). This is when a serious political conflict in the
Kosovo political scene, still reflected today in various ways, was conceived.
Namely, after the announcement of the election results, Thaqi proposed a
creation of a broad-based government of all parties where he would have the
prime ministerial post, hoping to secure for himself the post of prime minister
during whose office Kosovo would gain independence.
Rugova decided to form a coalition with Haradinaj rather than to create a
broad-based government. It was during the talks between LDK and AAK about the
formation of a joint government on November 6, 2004, that the Hague Tribunal
sent its request to question Haradinaj about his activities during the war. The
negotiations between the two parties were suspended for a time; and when, as it
was then generally believed in the province, Soren Jessen-Petersen (the then UN
special representative to Kosovo) arranged for the indictment postponement in
the Hague Tribunal, the coalition agreement was reached and Ramush Haradinaj was
appointed the new prime minister of Kosovo.
When analyzing political life and power distribution, it is easily noticed that
party affiliation is very important for obtaining public service positions as
well as for social approval.
Simultaneously, a strong network of traditional social division and tribal
loyalty is maintained, which makes the work of social and political institutions
in Kosovo very complex. The three most influential parties are chiefly led by
the wartime leaders.
The biggest LDK party was led by Ibrahim Rugova until his death, the AAK party
is led by Ramush Haradinaj, and the PDK is a party formed as a political
opponent of the KLA, with Hashim Thaqi as its leader. In the recent years, and
especially following the death of Ibrahim Rugova, analysts find, the LDK is no
longer a united national movement. Many intellectuals have left its ranks, and
much fewer individuals willing to maintain relations with other political
parties and to overcome differences have remained in the party (ICG, 2005: 16).
It is difficult to divine the exact number of assassinations carried out in the
post-war period over the LDK functionaries. Be it as it may, the number was
quite high and "sowed fear among the members of the party". A report of the
International Crisis Group stated: Although none of those murders were solved,
they are chiefly attributed to KLA and its successors (ICG, 2006: 17).
Disputes and rivalries in this area frequently have fatal outcomes due to the
large-scale revival of blood feuds, a custom previously suspended. Since the end
of the war in Kosovo in 1999 and by the end of 2003, 40 blood-feud related
murders were recorded in the Province, according to the data of the Council for
Defense of Human Rights and Freedoms, KLMDNJ. "Cases of blood vengeance are
reappearing as a consequence of the poor functioning of law and order and the
institutions that enforce laws", said Pajazit Nusi, the president of this
council (Bytiqi, 2004).
Numerous political murders, assassinations, chiefly committed under unresolved
circumstances and by unidentified perpetrators, have pushed into the background
the otherwise chronic problem of minority safety in some periods of post-war
Kosovo and Metohija, the foreground being held by the problem of inter-Albanian
conflicts and lately an increasingly marked expression of hostility toward the
representatives and institutions of the international community in the province.
Soon after the municipal election in 2000, Rugova's closest associate Xhemail
Mustafa was murdered at his home entrance. Several months later, Ismet Raci,
president of the Klina municipality and of the local LDK branch was also
murdered. After the parliamentary elections, Smail Hajdaraj, senior LDK official
and a member of the Kosovo parliament was killed. A day after the end of 2002
local elections, a high party official of Rugova's LDK and president of local
self-government in Suva Reka, Uke Bytiqi, was murdered. His two bodyguards were
also killed. The UNMIK police arrested two members of the rival PDK for this
murder. Murders and intimidations of the LDK officials continued over the
following years, and one of Rugova's followers stated that "intimidation was
preventing members from taking office and was responsible for a decrease in LDK
activism" (Qirezi, 2002).
Thus, the political life in Kosovo and Metohija does not have many similarities
with the usual mechanisms of political fighting: first of all, the strongest
political parties are led by former warriors, drawing their popularity and
influence from their participation in the 1998-1999 guerilla war against the
Serbian state, rather than professional politicians or experts in any field
(with the exception of Veton Surroi). Further, the usual methods of "political"
action are murders, blackmails, threats and robberies, which means that
political power is neither gained nor lost primarily in elections or through
other procedures of a regular political system, but depends on a variety of
personal, family (clan) and religious structures which are always ready to
bolster the persuasiveness of their "political" programs with violence.
A good part of current political life in Kosovo and Metohija has a criminal
background, both in terms of it being financed from suspicious sources and in
terms of the intertwinement of political structures with criminal gangs,
especially at local levels. In any event, the very programs of Albanian parties,
as well as the political debates among them, show that they are both similar and
different only regarding the speed and determination of the fight for
independence, whereas all other topics, predominant in normal circumstances
(economic, legal political, social, etc.), and are of less interest.
Hence it follows that, since the consensually accepted criterion of successful
political action is actually the ability and readiness to use any available
violent means to achieve independence, influential political parties may indeed
be led only by those who have built the appropriate paramilitary infrastructure
through guerrilla fighting and already tried the "alternative" mechanisms of
achieving political goals.
The Many Faces of Rivalry
Rivalry is reflected at various levels as a phenomenon in Kosovo and Metohija.
The most traditional and still strong form is regional rivalry. When we speak of
a similar phenomenon in Albania, the usual distinction is made between the
northern Gheg and southern Tosk tribes between which there is a centuries' long
feud over domination. In Kosovo and Metohija, although significantly smaller in
size, there are three culture-wise relatively distinct regions: Kosovo, Metohija
and Drenica.
An already deep-rooted regional rivalry is today intensified and interconnected
with political, military, business motivated rivalries, sometimes driving the
regional affiliation into the background. A certain balance was achieved
regionally by situating the capital in the very heart of the province although
the area of Metohija is traditionally the leading Albanian region of Kosovo. The
investigation of the presence of arms in Kosovo and Metohija organized by the
UNDP shows that the biggest quantity of illegal weapons is held by the
inhabitants of Pe , akovica and De ani (UNDP, 2004: 20).
The report also stated that the prices of weapons in this area are much lower
than in the central and eastern areas, which again indicates the weapon market
saturation. All this, along with maintenance of dominantly traditional relations
in social communication, has lead Western analysts to attribute a "Sicilian
flavor" to the Metohija region. Simultaneously, the Metohija population has
strong diaspora as well as kinship ties to Albanians living in Albania and
Montenegro. All this taken into consideration, the leading role of this area in
arms smuggling becomes clear. Describing the complex security situation in the
Pe area, Albanian analysts state: "In this region, law and order has broken down
and shootings have become part of the fabric of life. Acts of violence are
prompted by a variety of motives, ranging from rivalries left over from the
politics of the Kosovo conflict, through organized crime and business disputes,
to tit-for-tat blood feuds. It is sometimes hard to tell where one type ends and
the other starts, but the overall picture is of a gangland culture holding the
rest of society hostage." (Xhara et al ., 2005)
Intense war rivalry between two paramilitary Albanian formations of KLA (Kosovo
Liberation Army) and FARK (Armed Forces of the Republic of Kosovo), inconsistent
enforcement of laws, continuous fight for supremacy in organized crime and
trafficking, continuation of the blood feud custom, and so on constitute the
context which brought the Metohija region a high number of murders,
assassinations and altercations after the 1999 war (ICG, 2005: 7). It is
therefore no wonder that the international prosecutor described Pe as a town
which "resembles at time Chicago of the 1930s, with a per capita homicide rate
five times greater than the rest of Kosovo" (Xhara et al ., 2005). At the same
time, the resistance to both newly established institutions and to the UNMIK
presence is the strongest in this area. It is necessary to say that the
reputation of the UNMIK, although the lowest in this area, records continuous
decline in the entire Province: in November 2002, its work was approved by 63.8
percent Kosovo inhabitants, whereas in July 2004, its work was approved by only
20.7 percent (periodic "UNDP Reports of Early Warning").
The drop in popularity of and trust in UNMIK is accompanied with increasingly
open threats and attacks against this international institution. "By February
2005, indications given by former KLA circles in Dukagjin [ie: Metohija] were
not encouraging - a hardcore of several dozen were reportedly determined to hit
UNMIK, anywhere in Kosovo; some had already disappeared or figuratively 'gone to
the hills'." (ICG, 2005: 10)
In the security reports of various international institutions, the focal point
is the municipality of De ani, with several thousand chiefly unemployed KLA
members, and "the burgeoning post-KLA generation of eighteen to 22-year-olds
that local observers see as more radical and "trigger-happy" than the KLA
veterans, anxious for a chance to emulate their war" (ICG, 2005: 8). In further
description of the sentiments among the young, the same report states: "There is
a blithe recklessness about political consequences among the young men who
indulge in rhetoric about avenging Haradinaj and expelling UNMIK. Enthusiasm for
newspapers is low, unless it is their own 'war values' weekly Fokusi ... exude
an unhealthy air of military over-confidence. After the successive achievements
of the KLA, the UCPMB [LAPMB] in South Serbia's Presevo Valley, and the NLA in
Macedonia -- in all of which Dukagjini fighters played a part -- some are
tempted to see the solutions to Kosovo's problems in terms of one last military
push. Awash with weapons and eager young recruits, it would not take much for
the Decan groups to mobilize sizeable forces either to attack UNMIK or to
confront a Serbian military incursion into north Kosovo (a likely consequence of
any violent destabilization of the international presence in Kosovo). Former KLA
in Decan and Peja/Pe emphasize that conditions for a military campaign are far
better now than in 1997-1999: a secure hinterland, easier communications, more
experience, more arms, and a larger pool of fighters." (ICG, 2005: 9).
Experts assess that Kosovo inhabitants possess some 400,000 pieces of illegal
weapons. In the course of 2003, UNDP launched a three-month action of amnesty
for those who surrendered their weapons, which resulted in the yielding of 155
pieces of fire arms. The analysts see the reason for the failure of this action
in "a combination of continuing uncertainty over the final status of Kosovo,
distrust of the security forces, suspicions of corruption among local officials,
and a growing culture of violence", which Pristina sociologists explain in the
following manner: "Kosovar Albanians society is witnessing a rise in violence in
the home, in schools and in sport, there's a fascination with militarism and
army folklore is starting to dominate local culture" (Mustafa, Xhara, 2003).
At the pubic level, rivalry is manifested through constant mutual accusations
and threats, whereas at the secret level it is manifested in an uninterrupted
sequence of politically colored security incidents. Although the key functions
of authority have been gradually transferred from the UNMIK to local
institutions, this is yet to happen in the fields of internal security, defense,
judiciary and diplomatic relations.
Although there is an almost constant threat of peace violation and escalation of
violence in Kosovo and Metohija, situations in which the security is
additionally threatened to the extent that mobilizes all institutions dealing
with security in the province are numerous. One such situation was surely the
indictment against and delivery of Ramush Haradinaj (AAK) to The Hague. Quoting
their interview with a participant in the event, the authors of the Crisis Group
for Europe (ICG, 2005: 6) report state that in the days preceding the indictment
there had been significant transfer of arms from Pe to other towns in Kosovo,
including Pristina, whose inhabitants had noticed the arrival of "rough and rude
men". In the same report, the motives of the "rough newcomers" are identified
and revealed. They were "... armed fighters from disparate groups in Glo ani and
elsewhere came to Pristina to watch over UNMIK headquarters in early November
2004 when Haradinaj was questioned by ICTY investigators, and stood down only
when he emerged and convened a press conference to emphasize that his dealings
with the Tribunal were 'over'". (ICG, 2005: 10).
Allow us to remind you that the arrest of Ramush' brother, Daut Haradinaj, two
years earlier also caused commotion in this area, which resulted in an AAK
initiative submitted to the Kosovo Assembly to unanimously proclaim
independence.
The strongest surge of hostility by the Albanians against the Serbs remaining in
Kosovo and Metohija occurred in March 2004, in a true outbreak of violence which
followed an alleged murder of three Albanian boys. The consequences of the March
events were, in addition to some twenty killed Serbs, additional tens of
thousands of forcibly transferred ones, destroyed and damaged churches, huge
material damage on Serb homes and other structures.
Surprised by the vehemence and massiveness of Albanian violence in March,
international community institutions responded by placing barbed wire and sand
bags as protection for KFOR, KPS, and UN police buildings. The Albanian analyst
Jeta Xhara described the situation in those days: "As recently deployed British
reinforcements patrol Pristina, several streets in the centre of the city around
the UN headquarters and UN police central station have been sealed off for
civilian vehicles. Analysts fear the security forces can expect new attacks in
revenge for arrests of more than 200 people following the riot." (Xhara, 2004)
To this day, two and a half years after the violence against Serbs, no
indictments against the key agents have been processed. The media speculated
about the chief organizer - frequently ascribing this role to Fatmir Humoli,
chief of another of the numerous LK K (Levizja Kombetare lirimtare e Kosoves,
National Movement for the Liberation of Kosovo) formations, who made the
following statement in the same period: "It is obvious that political means have
produced no results, so we are now ready to use other means." (Koha ditore,
March 26th 2004) And, in a response to the scenario which could imply open
opposition to international community institutions present in the province, "the
UN officials have drawn an evacuation plan, which involves staff keeping money
aside for immediate withdrawal to Thessaloniki in northern Greece and
restricting their travel around the territory so that they can be pulled back to
Pristina rapidly" (Xhara, 2004).
Even the newly formed Kosovo Police Service (KPS) has difficulties in
accomplishing its task in some areas. The attitude of the De ani population
towards the KPS is especially illustrative. " The KPS there does not enjoy
unequivocal backing and is sometimes seen to conduct its duties "on tiptoe", not
wishing to offend local KLA sentiment. " (ICG, 2005: 9)
Another phenomenon essential for the understanding of the current security
architecture of post-war Kosovo is the rise in religiousness of the Albanian
population of Islamic faith. It is difficult to determine the degree of
Islamization of paramilitary Albanian formations objectively. The degree of
unapproachability and discretion that would accompany such a process would
certainly not leave much possibility for precise explanation of this phenomenon,
which has been intriguing both numerous intelligence services and media for some
time. In a sparse report, quoting an interview with Kosovo and Metohija
international police representatives, Tanjug news agency gives a piece of news
that the UNMIK police have launched an investigation on possible activities of
radical Islamists in the vicinity of Urosevac, because the police have found "a
quantity" of materials which may be connected to the activity of al-Qaida during
a search done in early August. "During a search of the house of a Kosovo
Albanian in the village of Talinovac near Urosevac, a quantity of materials
indicative of a connection to al-Qaida has been found", said an international
police official who wished to remain anonymous.
Even cursory observation makes it obvious that huge changes related to the
strengthening of religiousness have been happening in the territory of Kosovo
and Metohija for the last few years. Whereas 13 mosques have been built in the
municipality of Pristina in the 2000-2004 period, ( uri , 2005), the last two
years were marked with intensive building of a large number of new religious
Islamic structures throughout Kosovo, mass increase in the number of religious
schools, and the external signs of the strengthening of Islam are increasingly
obvious in the streets: a rich supply of religious books in the bookshop
windows, an increasing number of young people who indicate their affiliation to
Islam through a particular dressing style. This year, no one is any longer
surprised to see men who are adherent of the vehabi movement walking the streets
in characteristic beards and trousers with shortened legs.
In the period after the 1999 war, an entire network of various non-governmental,
humanitarian, and religious organizations was spread in Kosovo and Metohija.
Many of them carry out solely their legitimate activities and have played a
significant role in remedying the consequences of war by offering the population
their aid in food, medicines, and finding temporary housing. For many
organizations from a long list of the registered ones, however, there is a
justified suspicion of the true reasons for their presence in Kosovo and
Metohija as well as of the true nature of activities they carry out. One of
those is the El jilah organization, which is suspected of being a link between
Albanian drug dealers and Islamic countries. Another known Islamist organization
with developed activity in Kosovo is the Saudi Committee for Assistance to
People from Kosovo and Chechnya; and it is maintained that this organization
works intensively on the strengthening of Islam in the Albanian population.
Kosovo Liberation Army
Without entering into a broader elaboration of the rich historical experience of
the Albanians in joint resurgence enterprises and activities, we will focus only
on such type of joint enterprises in the period from the 1980s to date. The
1980s in the territory of Kosovo and Metohija were marked with mass gatherings
of Albanians, organized occurrences of violence and intensification of terrorist
attacks, which, as a rule, were aimed at the members of armed forces of the then
federal state.
In early 1990s, the Albanians from Kosovo and Metohija made more significant
connections with groups from diaspora, which resulted in the formation of an
organization named Popular Movement of Kosovo (LPK). This provided the
possibility for any further plans of action to be made by the extremist Albanian
emigration, which, being involved in a broad array of criminal activities in the
West, was also able to provide funding for accomplishment of Albanian goals.
Creation of such a reinforced infrastructure in turn additionally radicalized
the political demands of the Albanians and the basic goal of "independent
Kosovo" was shortly announced publicly. Soon, the process of formation of local
insurgent groups began and, until the mid-1990s, the main effort was to connect
thus created formations and to bring them under a common command. It is
maintained that a sort of "common headquarters" was formed in 1995, that it was
first situated in Podujevo, and then moved to the Gnjilane area.
As of mid-1990s, the bringing in of illegal military groups and individuals from
abroad intensifies. After the wars in Croatia and Bosnia, the Kosovo groups were
joined by the Albanians who have gained war experience in those regions.
Developments in the neighboring Albania in early 1997 were very significant for
the process of spreading and strengthening of the armed movement of Kosovo
Albanians. The big ferments in March 1997, accompanied with several weeks of
unrests, the fall of Pres. Sali Berisha' Government, complete falling apart of
law and order, also resulted in a plundering of the Albanian army weapons
storages. Over half a million pieces of plundered weapons quickly found its way
to the neighboring regions as well. The established situation of complete
anarchy in Albania provided the founders of the Kosovo Liberation Army "with
both a supply of small arms and a stretch of ungoverned territory in northern
Albania in which they could arm and train a guerrilla force" (ICG, 2004: 5).
The process of unification of increasingly numerous and massive individual
paramilitary organizations required a global consensus of the key players of
Albanian life, which was not reached until August 1998. Many later problems with
the functioning of the military hierarchy come partly from the fact that the
unification was somewhat late in coming. Some formations had already achieved
significant success at the level of military actions, accomplishing a domination
of power in the regions of their activity and were reluctant to agree to a loss
of their sovereign status. This is indeed the context in which numerous later
disputes and conflicts of different parts of the formation implied under the
common denomination of "Kosovo Liberation Army".
The 1997-1998 period was characterized with a fierce intensity of actions of
Albanian paramilitary troops, which, in contrast to the 1980s, also target the
civilian Serb population, driving them in massive numbers from numerous villages
in Metohija, and enter into open armed conflicts with the state authorities.
Intensive military activity of Albanian formations continued even during the
NATO air campaign.
Speaking of the nature of KLA, the IWPR analysts claim that it was a
"pan-Albanian force, which included many fighters from Macedonia and southern
Serbia, as well as Albanians with roots outside Kosovo" (Miftari, Quin, 2003).
Here, we will only mention another formation, the "Black Eagles", formed as a
special KLA unit, which was under the command of Idriz Balaj during the war. He
was convicted of torture and murder of several members of the rival FARK. In
February 2005, the members of this formation went public with a statement in
which they claim that "failure to take into consideration the pretences of
Kosovo Albanians will lead to reorganization of the guerrilla structures of the
KLA as a guarantee for accomplishment of a sovereign and independent state" [Epoha
e re, 18 shkurt 2005). It is maintained that a significant number of members of
this unit remain together today and that they are jointly involved in
trafficking and smuggling enterprise.
Formal Transition - KPC
Soon after the arrival of international forces to Kosovo and the establishment
of Interim Administrative UN Mission to Kosovo (UNMIK), a plan was designed for
the transformation of the Kosovo Liberation Army. Based on a Treaty ("Statement
on Demilitarization and Transformation of KLA"), which was signed by the first
KFOR commander Michael Jackson and the leader of the Kosovo Liberation Army
Hashim Thaqi on June 21, 1999, Kosovo Liberation Army was transformed into a
civilian institution. The Constitutional Framework for Provisional
Self-Government in Kosovo defines the newly established institution under the
name of "Kosovo Protection Corps" as: "a civilian emergency organization,
established under the law, which carries out in Kosovo rapid disaster response
tasks for public safety in times of emergency and humanitarian assistance".
The Regulation of the Special UN Representative for Kosovo defines the tasks of
the KPC in more detail. These are: removal of consequences of disasters,
provision of disaster response services, the performing of search and rescue,
provision of a capacity for humanitarian assistance in isolated areas,
assistance in demining, and contribution to rebuilding infrastructure in Kosovo.
Simultaneously, the following principles of the KPC activity are defined among
others: "service to all nations of Kosovo without any political connotation,
respect of internationally recognized treaties on human rights without any forms
of discrimination". All activities of the KPC, expert supervision and control
are under the authority of the special UN representative to Kosovo. It was
envisioned for the KPC to have 3,000 active and 2,000 reserve members. Out of
2,000 pieces of small infantry weapons planned for the needs of KPC, only 200
are in constant use, whereas 1,800 are in the KFOR storages. The KPC members
wear uniforms with insignia almost identical to those of the KLA, prevalent in
the former times.
The defined principle of operation that "each member, if he does not abide by
the provisions regulating work, is subject to criminal charges" has already
constituted grounds for punishment and suspension of a large number of the KPC
members. Based on the Proclamation 452 and Resolution 13219 of the US President
(which prohibits entry to the territory of the US and any financial or other
material support) from 2001, several senior KPC officers were "blacklisted" for
providing assistance to terrorist forces in Macedonia. Five senior officers
found themselves in prison, and four commanders of Operation Zones were
suspended. The following were put on the so-called "black list": Liberation Army
of Presevo, Medve a and Bujanovac (LAPMB), Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA),
National Liberation Army (ONA or NLA), National Movement for the Liberation of
Kosovo, Popular Movement of Kosovo, and the Political Council of Presevo, Medve
a and Bujanovac.
In addition to those armed groups, the list includes the names of eight KLA
members who are currently the KPC officers (Sami Lushtaku, Daut Haradinaj, Ramiz
Ladrovci, Rustem Mustafa, Rexhep Selimi), three members of the LAPMB (Shefqet
Musliu, Muhamet Xhemaili, Shaqir Shaqiri), nine members of NLA (Ali Ahmeti,
Xhevat Ademi, Nura Bexhet, Xhavit Hasani, Gezim Ostreni, Hisni Shaqiri, Emrush
Suma, Fazli Veliu and Kastriot Haxhirexha), one member of the National Movement
for the Liberation of Kosovo (Sabit Gashi), two members from the ranks of the
Popular Movement of Kosovo (Gafur Elshani, Emrush Xhemaili) and two members each
from the Political Council of PMB (Tahir Dalipi and Jonuz Musliu) and the Party
for Democratic Progress of Kosovo (Skender Habibi and Azem Sulja).
The operation of the KPC is financed from the budget of the province, with
significant funds inflow, however, being made through donations, which again
opens the possibility to connect the KPC with parts of criminal emigration and
organizations of suspicious character. The most infamous among such
organizations is the "Friends of the KPC", with the seat in Switzerland.
Although it is officially registered in Germany as well, UNMIK prohibited its
activity in Kosovo after the insight into the criminal activities carried out by
the members of the "Friends of the KPC". Another organization, with a longer
history of financing the activities of Albanian formations in Kosovo, "Homeland
Calling" also has a widespread network of branches in West Europe.
It is questionable to what extent this formal transformation has actually
stopped the activity of KLA. The International Crisis Group (ICG, 2006) states
that some 2,000 of the KLA members transferred to the KPC and that the same
number entered the ranks of the new-formed the Kosovo Police Service (KPS). A
certain number of people from the highest KLA leadership entered politics and
today hold significant positions in the political life of the province: Hashim
Thaqi, Ramush Haradinaj, Agim eku, Jakup Krasniqi. Where are other former KLA
members and does their participation in the demilitarization program, conducted
in 1999 by the International Organization for Migrations (IOM), denote the end
of their military ambitions?
Some analysts maintain that the KLA, despite its disbanding and formal
transformation, has fully kept its operative core, and that, in the years after
the war, it even broadened its field of activity, joining the military
operations in southern Serbia and Macedonia. An illustration for this claim is
the destiny of the Chief of Staff of the KPC, Gezima Ostreni, who went to
Macedonia in 2001 and became the leader of National Liberation Army (NLA). Agim
eku suspended Ostreni in the KPC. Also, Shukri Buja, the commander of the KPC
Zone 6, was removed from office after the charges that he provided aid in the
smuggling of arms to the sourthern Serbia for the needs of the LAPMB.
The NATO sources point to the existence and occasional activity of several
Albanian armed groups: Liberation Army of Presevo, Medve a and Bujanovac, Armed
Forces of Republika Kosova, National Liberation Army, Popular Movement for
Kosovo, Liberation Army of Eastern Kosovo, Albanian National Army; and have also
registered the activities of the Liberation Army of Gusinje and Plav in
Montenegro, as well as of the Liberation Army of Chaimeria in Greece. The fact
that a large number of separate military organizations has been formed in
post-war Kosovo is confirmed by the ICG report, which states, among other
things, that "These military and ex-military groupingss are only loosely
connected with each other" (ICG, 2005: 10).
In the Report from the Special Research Project of the IWPR "KLA Under Scrutiny"
reminds us that the international community "began openly talking about the
links between the protectorate's civil defense force, the Kosovo Protection
Corps, and the militant Albanian group the Albanian National Army, ANA, which
aims to rid Kosovo of its remaining Serb population" in May 2003 (Miftari, Quin,
2003).
Although the Albanian National Army - ANA - took the responsibility for the
mining of the bridge near the Serb town of Zve an in northern Kosovo in April
2003, it turned out that active members of KPC were involved in the planning of
this bombing. Two persons were killed on the occasion due to inexpert placement
of the explosives in the bridge construction, and one of them was a KPC member.
For suspicion of possible involvement in this bombing, 12 persons, former KLA
members and KPC members after the war, were soon arrested. The arrests caused a
strain in relations between the KPC headquarters and UNMIK. The then-commander
of KPC, Agim eku, "reacted angrily, saying there was no evidence against his
men" (Mustafa, Xhara, 2003). A long questioning procedure ensued, and, during
the investigation, the object of inquiry of the judiciary broadened from the
bridge bombing to include the cases of trafficking in humans and arms smuggling.
In December 2003, the KFOR issued a statement saying that the 12 suspects from
the ranks of the KPC would be suspended for six months during which an
investigation into their involvement in the assault was to be conducted.
Criticizing the idea and achievements of post-war KLA transformation, father
sava Janji from Visoki De ani monastery writes: "The best indicator of the
'credibility' of KPC -- for which western taxpayers have generously given
millions of dollars through their governments -- is the sheer fact that almost
all its post-war leaders are now either in prison, have been suspended for
various violations, or have been added to President George Bush' blacklist, an
impressive record for an organization that was proclaimed as a great post-war
success in Kosovo." (Father Sava in Decani, 2002)
"Kosovo Army"?
Dissatisfaction with their assigned role and efforts to modify the resolution
defining this organization as civilian so as to provide for its status as a
legitimate military formation arose very early within the KPC. In late April
2002, an official request to UNMIK was initiated to revise the resolution. The
request was rejected by the UN special representative, the solution for the
growing discontent of an increasing number of KPC members being postponed for
"better times". That those "better times" for KPC may well be nearing is hinted
at in the most recent report of the International Crisis Group, which, along
with the prediction that the "international community is just months away from
decisions that are expected to make Kosovo a state", adds that "a key component
of post-independent security structures should be an army built in part upon the
Kosovo Protection Corps (KPC)..." (ICG, 2006). The report further states that
there are no conditions in Kosovo for full demilitarization and that a
demilitarized Kosovo would become "a facade, behind which unofficial
paramilitary groups would coalesce". Such a newly formed army, ICG concludes
optimistically, could lead to the creation of a "stable, multi-ethnic or at
least ethnically neutral identity of the new state... With its partial evolution
from paramilitary roots, dependency on NATO expertise, and willingness to
undergo substantial change, KPC offers it an opportunity to exercise a free hand
in molding the army that it should not refuse." ICG also recommends the profile
of such an army, which should consists of "small, lightly-equipped, multi-ethnic
force of between 2,000 and 3,000 personnel, trained by a dedicated NATO mission
to a transparent plan and schedule, and brought to operational capability by
2011-2012". Aware of possible regional risks inherent in stronger armament of
such a military formation, ICG maintains that the newly formed Kosovo army must
have "no tanks, heavy artillery, ground-to-ground missiles or attack aircraft -
until such time as both Kosovo and Serbia join NATO's Partnership for Peace (PfP)
program".
KLA vs. FARK
One of the fiercest military rivalries is certainly that between the units of
the Kosovo Liberation Army and the FARK members.
Begun since the very formation in 1990s, intensified during the war, escalated
in the summer of 1999, this rivalry still has significant effect on security
structures in the province. Manifestations of this rivalry in various contexts
reflect all the complexity of inter-Albanian relations and explains many
post-war security incidents and much of the re-structuring. Therefore this line
of conflict deserves a more detailed review. KLA originates from the Popular
Movement of Kosovo, despite the fact that other organizations and movements were
also active at the time. The analysts would later establish that "LPK gained a
lead over rival Albanian groups because, in part, the international community
took them more seriously than others". This view is illustrated by the
recollections of a foreign diplomat in an interview to the IWPR: "Out of the
several guerrilla groups that were operating in Kosovo, the LPK were the group
we considered to be the most serious" (Miftari, Quin, 2003). The favoring of LPK,
and later KLA, as a "serious" military formation has deepened an already
deep-rooted dispute between this formation and that founded by Rugova's
government in exile - FARK. Although Ibrahim Rugova publicly promoted the policy
of passive resistance in 1990s, his prime minister in exile Bujar Bukoshi
conducted intensive fund-raising and enlisting of volunteers for execution of
terrorist attacks and participation in the armed fights in Kosovo. As the IWPR
analysts conclude: "But indecisiveness over the right time to strike meant that
few of the planned attacks ever materialised, and the FARK remained largely
ineffective." (Miftari, Kvin, 2003). Frustrated with such ineffectiveness, a
group of activists from the Popular Movement of Kosovo (LPK) set up the
"Homeland Calling" ["Vendlindja therret ") fund and stepped up its effort at
collecting money, mobilizing fighters within Kosovo and carrying out operations
on the ground.
The growing success of LPK marginalized the status of FARK. This caused the
attempt of Bujar Bukoshi to make Ibrahim Rugova "the supreme commander of all
ethnic Albanian forces fighting in the province" to be rejected by the Albanian
resurgents. Bukoshi attempted to save the position of FARK by organizing a
meeting with the LPK representatives in Instanbul in the spring of 1997.
Although the main goal of the meeting was to establish a joint strategy for
future action, that did not come to be, either during the Instabul meeting or in
several following meetings mediated by the government of Albania. The KLA
representatives justified their refusal to cooperate with the FARK with the
explanation that Bukoshi was insincere and that he only wanted to enable the
government in exile to take control of the KLA. Disputes occurred on the ground
as well, and there were no joint actions. The depth of division between the key
figures in the KLA and FARK is illustrated by a quote from a book published in
2003 by the assassinated FARK general, tahir Zemaj, to whom Hashim Thaqi told:
"I will fight you, Tahir Zemaj, as though you were Serbs, I will fight you and
your units." (Ahmetaj, Krasniqi, 2000) After this dispute, Zemaj left for
Tirana; he did not return to Kosovo until 2001, and was assassinated in Pe in
2003, together with his son and son-in-law.
Soon after the end of the NATO air campaign against Serbia, two power structures
formed in Kosovo. Thaqi became prime minister with support in the KLA, ceding
the position of the supreme commander to Agim eku. Regional KLA commanders were
also appointed to positions of responsibility in the zones where they commanded
the KLA units: Rustem Mustafa in the Lab region, Ramush Haradinaj in Metohis,
Sami Lushtaku in Drenica, Gezim Ostreni in Pastriku, Shukti Buja in the Karadak
region, and Rrahman Rama in Salja (ie: Upper Lab). Ibrahim Rugova set up his
provisional government and it was not until December 1999, after several weeks
of conflict-ridden negotiations, that those two provisional governments were
disbanded. UNMIK promised Rugova and Thaqi equal inclusion in new province
structures, as well as appointment of the LDK and PDK members for section chiefs
in the interim UNMIK administration, which came to pass in February 2000.
Rivalry in Intelligence Activities
The overall security chaos in the province was significantly heightened by the
parallel and competing activities of several intelligence services. In the years
after the war, the following were active in this area: Intelligence Agency of
Kosovo (AIK), National Intelligence Service of Kosovo (KSHIK), Albanian National
Service, "Eagle Eye", Albanian National Secret Service, Albanian National
Security, Fighters and Protectors of Albanian National Territories. In addition,
the Intelligence Section of the Chief Headquarters (G-2), known under the name
of SHIU (Sherbim Informativ Ushtarak ) within the KPC is also involved in
intelligence activities. A part of staff of this organization was made up of
individuals from the KLA Military Police, who were involved in intelligence work
both before and during the war. Within the Kosovo Police Service, a body was set
up for intelligence work - the KPS Intelligence Service (Sherbim Informativ SHPK
). A former member of special units of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of
Serbia, subsequently a senior KLA officer, heads this service.
For present-day Kosovo and Metohija, the activities of the two dominant,
otherwise rival, intelligence groups, both linked to the intelligence party
sector are the most interesting to follow (Lulzim Peci, TV debate "Life in
Kosovo", November 23, 2005, RTK). Those services, until then discreet in public
appearances but very active in their operation, were given a stimulus to appear
in the public by the initiative of the UN Mission in Kosovo to allow formation
of the Ministries of Justice and Internal Affairs in the province. It was the
starter shot to the race in which the competitors wished to gain the best
position they could and to secure a dominant place in the planned security
structures. Simultaneously, a successful crossing of the finish line offered a
possibility to legitimize former, in a good part criminal, activities of those
party services.The statement of one of the key players in this process should be
taken in this sense: "The time has come to demystify these intelligence
structures and show we are real people and not monsters." (Xhara, 2005)
We will provide brief introduction of two main intelligence groups which are
still operating covertly in Kosovo. The KIPRED report suggests that the
activities of those two groups "range from protection of party interests to
information gathering and intimidation of political rivals".
To understand the nature of relations between them, it is important to recall
that they were formed as an expression of opposition between the KLA and FARK.
The Kosovo Intelligence Agency - AIK (Agjencia Informative e Kosoves ) - was
formed to meet the needs of the FARK, a paramilitary formation formed under the
patronage of Rugova's LDK. This agency operates under the guise of a
non-governmental organization of the Institute for Public Opinion and Strategy
research (IHPSO), headed by Rame Maraj, former Rugova's special advisor for
security and, as many claim, his top man of confidence. After the war, the
agency continued to deal with intelligence issues for the politically dominant
LDK. IHPSO draws its roots from the "ministries" of defense and internal affairs
formed by the Kosovo parallel government in exile in 1990s (Xhara, 2005). The
initiator and creator of those institutions was Bujar Bukoshi, the prime
minister of Rugova's shadow government, and all this occurred in Germany in the
second half of the 1990s.
An event that speeded up the disclosure of facts already anticipated by everyone
about the secret intelligence war concerns the investigation launched after the
unsuccessful assassination attempt against Rugova. As assessed by Albanian
analysts and as confrmed by the investigation intiated by the UNMIK and KPS, an
opinion is crystallizing "that the elements within the LDK ranks are responsible
for this explosion". It is suspected that the planted bomb, which damaged
Rugova's car and injured a passer-by, was to provide the president with an
excuse to avoid acceptance of a broad coalition in power.
There ensued a quick reaction by the Kosovo and UNMIK police, whose members
broke into the Kosovo Presidency at midnight and seized the equipment of
Rugova's parallel police.
It was followed by Hashim Thaqi's act that was intended to discredit Rugova's
LDK additionally. PDK submits an initiative to the Kosovo parliament to launch
and investigation into the activity of the Kosovo Vice President Adem Salihaj
from LDK and three ministers, his fellow party members, who were accused by the
PDK of being behind the Safety of the Homeland organization, which was again,
allegedly, behind some political murders and the bombing attack on Veton
Surroi's Ora party. And, although Kosovo parliament rejected the initiative to
launch the investigation, the public got the possibility to view some 500-page
long file with accusations against senior LDK officials.
The IHPSO is thought to have some 300 staff, half of whom receive their regular
monthly salaries of some 200 euros per month from this organization, whereas the
other half is employed in the municipal and other public services. A part of the
employees are former servants of the National Security Service. As claimed by
the authors of the Balkan Insight report, quoting a source close to the IHPSO,
who wished to remain anonymous, this organization is in part financed from
donations of Kosovo Albanians in diaspora. It also receives a part of the bribe
local business people pay to the LDK in hope of winning the tenders for
reconstruction projects and other works (Xhara, 2005).
The rival, National Intelligence Service of Kosovo (Kombetar Sherbimi Informativ
e Kosoves - KSHIK), is linked to the leading opposition party - Hashim Thaqi's
Democratic Party of Kosovo. KSHIK evolved from the Popular Movement of Kosovo (LPK).
More accurately, it was formed in April 1999 through the transformation of the "Zbulimi
kunder zbulimit (ZKZ)" counter-intelligence agency. ZKZ had a two-year
experience in intelligence operations within the KLA and a developed
infrastructure throughout Kosovo, so that the majority of members were taken
over by the newly formed agency at the time of transformation of the ZKZ into
the KHIK. Although formed during the operation of the Provisional Kosovo
Government of Hashim Thaqi, the agency continued its operation even after this
government was ended in February 2000.
Continuing its operation in accordance with its roots, this agency claims the
right to financing from the collected money remaining after the war in the
Homeland Calling fund, from which the KLA had been financed. Additional
financing is provided from donations and local followers' aid.
Today, this organization is quite open regarding its activities. Kadri Veselji,
Hashim Thaqi's man of confidence, a member of his Provisional Government, and
presently the director of KSHIK, does not deny that he manages the intelligence
gathering operations. "We have been in the transformation process, for the last
five years", he told the researchers from the Balkan Insight, adding that KSHIK
hoped to have "a more active role" in future in such a way that the "capacities
of this organization would be nationalized" (Xhara, 2005). Jakup Krasniqi, the
head of the PDK parliamentary group, asked the Kosovo parliament "to accept SHIK
as a legitimate part of the Kosovar Intelligence Service, which is to work
inside the newly established interior ministry" (Mustafa, 2005).
Summing up the results of the rivalry between those two agencies, the Balkan
Insight analysts mention a large number of murders of the LDK party officials,
which caused anxiety among the members of this party. Although almost all
murders remain unsolved, they are attributed to the groups linked to the Kosovo
Liberation Army (KLA). The dispute was especially heated up by the events
surrounding the surrender of Ramush Haradinaj when KSHIK and IHPSO "were deeply
involved in the efforts of their parties to profit as much as possible in the
period of political uncertainty that then ensued" (Xhara, 2005).
In early 2003, members of the newly formed Homeland Security organization showed
up at the funeral of the murdered FARK general Tahir Zemaj. The following year,
that organization, which identifies itself with the FARK forces and claims that
its task is to monitor the LDK, issued several statements in which it threatened
violence to party "deserters" and their families if they tried to drag more
members out of the party before the elections. The statement by this
organization that it enjoyed confidence of president Rugova caused quite an
uproar in the Kosovo public. "An LDK official claimed its intelligence service
is taking over the party, from which platform it also endeavors to take over the
government and secure its economic interests. Electoral success and the
coalition with the AAK have given that intelligence service the confidence to
dispense with the sharing of spoils with the PDK and its intelligence service
that marked the broad multiparty coalition of 2002-2004." (ICG, 2005: 18)
Albanian National Army - ANA (Armata kombetare shqiptare - AKSH): A Post-War
Accomplishment
It is believed that the Albanian National Army - ANA - was established in 2001
at the time of conflicts between ethnic Albanians and the Macedonian security
forces. It built its reputation through a veritable virtual war for publicity,
most often through international web sites, with a basic motto that it was the
only Albanian military formation active in the territory of Kosovo, Macedonia
and southern Serbia after the war. And whereas other paramilitary formations -
KLA, ONA and LAPMB - at least verbally rejected the demand for pan-Albanian
unification, ANA has the creation of "Greater Albania" as the main goal of its
program. When ANA took trhe responsibility for the bombing of the Zve an bridge
in 2003, the then administrator Michael Steiner designated it as terrorist.
In demonstrations staged in February and March 2003 in De ani, the protest was
against the UNMIK sentence against the so-called Dukagjin group of the KLA
members, who were charged with torture and murder of the FARK soldiers in the
summer of 1999. In those demonstrations, the crowd cheered the ANA and, though
many western analysts were inclined to designate this formation as an "Internet
army", its presence was becoming increasingly obvious in the territory of De ani,
akovica and Istok. Ever more frequent patrols by persons in black uniforms,
interception and ID inspection of passers-by, setting up of checkpoints, even
incidents in which policemen were disarmed, pointed to the strengthening of the
stronghold of this organization in the territory of Metohija.
By their official statement which was intended to deny the spreading of problems
with the ANA, especially the incident with the disarming of the KPS and UNMIK
police, the competent security structures actually provided a clear confirmation
of the spreading of the new paramilitary: "The competent police sources reject
any idea that the patrol was disarmed. Having encountered several masked persons
armed with the AK-47 rifles at night, the patrol car drove away from the
checkpoint and waited for backup units. When the backup units arrived, the
masked and armed assailants fired several shots and escaped through the woods
and fields. The police sources also deny that the patrols were reduced
afterwards and emphasize that the presence of non-uniformed police, as well as
subsequent KFOR ambushes in the woodland areas along roads where the activity of
the ANA members was reported, were actually increased." (ICG, 2005: 8)
Is it really necessary to raise the question of safety of the "woodland" areas
which are not situated along any significant roads?
The emergence of a new paramilitary formation has stirred up the area of Drenica.
In April 2004, at the fifth anniversary of the death of two KLA members, several
masked persons "emerged from behind the hill, approached the crowd and read a
speech on behalf of the Albanian National Army, ANA, in which they called for a
'fight for the freedom' of Albanian lands that are not controlled by KFOR and
for Albanian interests wherever they are" (Salihu et al ., 2004). It mimicked
the manner in which the masked members of the KLA appeared in in this area at
the funeral of their killed fellow soldier on November 27, 1997.
In reaction to the similarity of appearance of this organization in public,
Rexhep Selimi, an AAK member and former KLA commander, wrote a comment with the
indicative title of "Beware Cheap Copies" (Selimi, 2004). Pointing out that the
ANA actions were "unnecessary, unproductive and lacking in strategy", Selimi
fears that they could "risk tainting the image of the Kosovar Albanian war of
liberation" and criticizes the practice of the ANA member who were "stopping
vehicles in the middle of the night, demanding to check villagers' IDs and
checking whether the travelers they encounter are on certain 'lists'".
The IWPR report authors state that they have managed to contact a person who
claims to be a member of the ANA organization. "He said the militants are a
guerrilla movement, active throughout Kosovo not just in the western region. The
group is organized so individual members have no idea who else is involved, he
said, adding they are not fighting KFOR but those who work against the interest
of Albanians." The report then conveys the sentiment of the Pe residents toward
the appearance of a new armed group in their midst. They appeared unconcerned
and "some even support its goals, saying radical action is needed to ensure
independence is the outcome of the negotiations on Kosovo's status." (Limani,
Kelmendi, 2005).
As stated in the International Crisis Group report from May 2005 (ICG, 2005):
"Kosovo's society has a residual addiction to the clandestine -- a preference
for focusing on shadow rather than daylight and upon the hidden rather than the
open agenda." And, as the last illustration of such a pattern, the report quotes
the threatening statements and calls that the ANA issued in March 2005 to all
former Albanian armies to become active again: the KLA in Kosovo, the ONA in
Macedonia, and the LAPMB in southern Serbia. Such a call was accompanied with a
demand to the institutions to form a Kosovo police intelligence service.
Numerous incidents followed: the bombings throughout Kosovo, blown up or shot UN
vehicles in akovica and Pe , hand grenades thrown at the UNMIK head office,
shots at the telecommunications node on top of the UNMIK head office, shots at
the police communications node at Pristina airport. The ANA has appeared with
the statement in which it accepted responsibility for them in the following
words:
"We have received the blessing from the people to start a new fight for dignity
and independence, to fulfill the will of the generation that sacrificed itself
for freedom and independence... Last night's explosions in many Kosovo towns are
just a warning that there are people who love freedom and await its call, people
who do not fear either death or enemies, however strong they may be. We will
allow no one to push this country into the abyss... We are resolute in our
intention to accomplish our goals peacefully, but will not reject the concept of
armed fight ... our structures have been preparing intensively for seven months
already." (March 4, 2005)
Only a few days later, on 15 March, a remote controlled device exploded in
Pristina downtown in the moment when the trash can in which it was placed was
passed by a line of cars accompanying the then president of Kosovo, Ibrahim
Rugova. The incident ended with injured passers-by and damaged Rugova's vehicle.
This incident remains unsolved and the police were surprised with Rugova's
refusal to talk about the assassination attempt. The public, recalling a similar
incident in 2004, when a hand grenade exploded in the yard of Rugova's home,
designed varying explanations for itself, with increasingly frequent claims that
the two incidents were indeed faked by Rugova's security staff.
Conclusions
The presented material shows that seven years after the end of war the Albanian
political players in Kosovo and Metohija have not transformed their activities
in a direction which would allow for a prospect of a civil society with
institutions ensuring personal safety, respect of legal standards, conditions
for normal business activities, accomplishment of social rights, infrastructure
supply and, generally, all those functions of a state implied by normal life in
a European society at the beginning of the 21st century.
On the one hand, the very political life is occurring in a tight relationship
with criminal groups, which prevents any principled effort and discussion which
would not be supported with sheer force and suspicious financing. On the other
hand, it appears that various Albanian players, from purely political, through
para-political, para-humanitarian and intelligence, to paramilitary and criminal
ones - torn by their old and new disputes and struggle for power sources - are
not able to reach a minimum consensus which would guarantee at least personal
(physical and property) safety to the members of the Albanian people, even with
the assistance of international institutions.
Data on the dependence of the political life on arms smuggling, human and drug
trafficking, etc. and on the rates of various forms of crime (murders,
abductions, robberies, extortions), which even intensified in the post-war
period, show that crime is a structurally embedded phenomenon in present-day
Kosovo-Metohija life and that, at least without deep systemic changes, it is a
factor that cannot be eliminated from political relationships. The data also
show that crime permeates and destroys all segments of social life to the extent
that the state cannot guarantee its citizens even elementary rights. This
corroborates the assessment that things would be worse still in the event of
(partial or conditional) independence, since the mechanisms through which
Albanian political agents could stamp out or curb the rampaging crime are not
nowhere in sight.
The presented situation points to some paradoxical conclusions: although the
declared (according to the official views of Albanian politicians) and at first
glance actual obstacles to accomplishment of civil society in Kosovo and
Metohija are the inter-ethnic tensions between the Albanians and Serbs, as well
as the presence of international factors and their execution of key functions of
state authority, the analysis of the described developments could even hint at
the fact that Serbs, Roma or Gorani actually constitute an integrative element
for the Albanian ethnic majority; ie: that their very (drastically diminished
and unwanted) presence contributes to the homogenization of Albanian political
and para-political groups.
Similar is true for the imposition of legal and political standards by the
international factors. If those "external" sources of homogenization were to
disappear and if Albanian players were to be left to themselves, those frictions
and disagreements would just intensify, because, on the one hand, there would be
no external control over political processes, and because, on the other, the
vacant political space (ie: the division of any newly gained leverages of power)
would generate new conflicts.
Since practically no Albanian party offers any concept of a different shaping of
social relations after the demanded gaining of independence even in their
programs, it may be easily assumed that new struggles for political, military,
and economic influence on the social scene would start as soon as on the "day
after"; and, judging by the experience to date, such a struggle would only be
limited by the means available to wage such conflict.
Such a conclusion is also supported by the fact that, regardless of the
prevalence of violence against the Serbs and members of other minorities, crime
affecting Albanians themselves has also risen sharply for the past seven years.
Albanians are probably the most numerous victims of the disorderly situation,
which keeps being perpetuated, without any serious indications of improvement.
Those institutions of power (and, generally, services, both of infrastructure
and suprastructure) which the international powers handed over to local factors
-- ie: authorities and public enterprises held by the Albanians themselves -- do
not show any capability to perform their basic activities, quite independently
from the attitude toward the minority members.
Crime and corruption, in which many international officials are also involved,
thus remain a constant of the Kosovo-Metohija society and its political
structures.
The Author:
Dr Sla ana uri , is a Professor at Belgrade University's Faculty of Security.
Bibliography:
Bytiqi Fatos, Blood Feuds Revive in Unstable Kosovo (BCR No 481, 19-Feb-04),
available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=158066&apc_state=henibcr2004
Bytiqi Fatos, Kosovo: Fury Over KPC Arrests (BCR No 345, 26-Jun-02)
uri , Sla ana, "Some Parameters of Social Life in Kosovo in the Period Since the
Establishment of the UN Interim Administration Mission ", Prepared as a
submitted paper for Conference Strategy 2005, Washington
Father Sava in Decani, Comment: Kosovo Extremists Out of Control (BCR No 355,
2-Aug-02), available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=250024&apc_state=henibcr2002
ICG, An Army for Kosovo?, Europe Report N deg. 174, 28 July 2006.
ICG, Kosovo after Haradinaj, Europe Report N deg. 163, 26 May 2005.
ICG, Kosovo: The Challenge of Transition , Europe Report N deg. 170, 17 February
2006.
ICG, Kosovo: Toward Final Status, Europe Report N deg. 161, 24 January 2005.
ICG, Pan-Albanism: How Big A Threat to Balkan Stability? Europe Report N deg.
153, 25 February, 2004.
ICG, What Happened to the KLA? , Europe Report N deg. 88, 3 March 2000.
IWPR staff in London, Kosovo: KLA Men Indicted (BCR No 408, 20-Feb-03),
available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=158160&apc_state=henibcr2003
Kamberi Belgzim, Xhara Jeta, ANA Fails to Stir Albanian Passions (BCR N deg.
461, 25-sep-2003) Kelmendi Adriatik, Comment: KLA Trials Harm Reconciliation (BCR
N deg. 445, 18-Jul-03), available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=156596&apc_state=henibcr2003
Keshtu foli Tahir Zemaj , Internet version available at: http://www.forumishqiptar.com/showthread.php?t=34988
Krasniqi Petrit, Albanians Spurn K-FOR, BCR No. 157, 18 July, 2000 Latifi
Skender, Kosovo Union Calls Raise Tensions (BCR No 532, 09-Dec-04), available
at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=154963&apc_state=henibcr2004
Limani Zana, Kelmendi Ibrahim, Armed Group Roams Western Kosovo, Institute for
war & peace reporting - IWPR, 21 October, 2005, available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=256847&apc_state=hsribcr200510
Miftari Naser, Quin David, Policing the Protectors [BCR No 440, 30-Jun-03),
available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=156839&apc_state=henibcr2003
Mustafa Artan, Kosovars Concerned New Ministries May be Politicised (BCR No 567,
27-Jul-05), available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=257081&apc_state=henibcr200507
Mustafa Artan, Xhara Jeta, Kosovo Gun Amnesty Setback [BCR 464, 16-Oct-03),
available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=155804&apc_state=henibcr2003
Mustafa Artan, Xhara Jeta, Kosovo Officers Under Investigation [BCR No 472,
11-Dec-03), available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=155039&apc_state=henibcr2003
Peci Lulzim, television debate "Life in Kosovo ", 23 November 2005, RTK Qirezi
Arben, Kosovo: Election Marred by Political Killing (BCR No 378, 31-Oct-02),
http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=155866&apc_state=henibcr2002
Qirezi Arben, Kosovo: KLA Trial Backlash [BCR No 449, 31-Jul-03), available at:
http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=156540&apc_state=henibcr2003 Qirezi Arben,
Kosovo: UN Facing Backlash (BCR No. 361, 23-Aug-02), available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=249934&apc_state=henibcr2002
Qirezi Arben, Kosovo: Witness Protection Fears Grow [BCR No 426, 29-Apr-03),
available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=157429&apc_state=henibcr2003
Qirezi Arben, Old Foes Unite to Form New Kosovo Government (BCR No 528,
19-Nov-04), available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=155301&apc_state=henibcr2004
Rexhepi Fehim, "Bujanovac, Medve a, Presevo, mogu a ta ka sukoba?", Pristina, 5
February, 2000, AIM Pristina Rexhepi Fehim, Ilegalne organizacije na Kosovu?!,
WED, 15 DEC 1999 07:55:32 GMT, AIM Pristina, 14 December, 1999, available at:
http://www.aimpress.ch/dyn/pubs/archive/data/199912/91215-017-pubs-pri.htm
Salihu Arben, Hajrullahu Muhamet, Xhara Jeta, Radicals Test the Ground in
Drenica [BCR No 498, 20-May-04), available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=157073&apc_state=henibcr2004
Selimi Rexhep, Comment: Beware of Cheap Copies (BCR No 498, 20-May-04),
available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=157077&apc_state=henibcr2004
UNDP (juni 2004), "Light Blue, Public Perceptions of Security and Police
Performance in Kosovo", available at: http://www.kosovo.undp.org/PoliceSurveyReport_Eng.pdf
Constitutional Framework for Provisional Self-Government (Ustavni okvir za
privremenu samoupravu), UNMIK/REG/2001/9, 15 May, 2001, available at: http://pristina.usmission.gov/serbs/sdoc2.htm
Xhara Jeta, Hajrulahu Muhamet, Salihu Arben: Kosovo's Wild West, Institute for
war & peace reporting (IWPR), February 18, 2005, available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?apc_state=hsrfbcr242391&l=en&s=f&o=242392
Xhara Jeta, ANA Fails to Stir Albanian Passions (BCR No 461, 25-Sep-03),
available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=156016&apc_state=henibcr2003
Xharra Jeta, Kosovo Radicals Turn on UN and NATO [BCR No 489, 26-Mar-04),
available at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=157655&apc_state=henibcr2004
Xharra Jeta, Kosovo: ANA Menace Growing? (BCR No 430, 16-May-03), available at:
http://www.iwpr.net/?p=bcr&s=f&o=157183&apc_state=henibcr2003
Constitutional Framework for Provisional Self-Government, UNMIK/REG/2001/9
May 15, 2001, available at: http://pristina.usmission.gov/serbs/sdoc2.htm
Footnotes:
1. Available at http://www.pristina.usmission.gov/
2. Available at http://www.unmikonline.org/
3. Available at http://www.nato.int/kfor/
4. Available at http://www.osce.org/kosovo/
5. Available at http://www.crisisgroup.org/
6. Available at http://www.kosovo.undp.org/
7. Available at http://www.iwpr.net/
8. Texts and analyses in the publication of Balkan Insight, internal publication
of the regional Balkan Investigative Reporting Network, available at http://www.birn.eu.com/kosovo/
See also other recent reporting:
Defense & Foreign Affairs Special Analysis, September 29, 2006: Meeting the
Burden of Statehood: Is Kosovo Ready?
Defense & Foreign Affairs Special Analysis, January 31, 2007: Arms Smuggling
Routes Enhance Extremist Capabilities in South-West Balkans; Albanian
Separatists Expected to Mobilize in Spring if Kosovo Does Not Get Independence .
Defense & Foreign Affairs Special Analysis, February 2, 2007: As Ahtisaari Plan
Delineates Essentially Independent Kosovo, Jihadists Move to Expand Ops in FYROM,
Greece, Serbia .
Defense & Foreign Affairs Special Analysis, February 28, 2007: Kosovo Albanian
Power Struggles and Attendant Factors Overwhelm UNMIK Capacities as Major
Violence Looms .
Defense & Foreign Affairs Special Analysis, March 1, 2007: Terrorism and
Organized Crime in South-Eastern Europe: The Case of Bosnia-Herzegovina, Sanzak,
and Kosovo.
Copyright 2007 Defense & Foreign
Affairs/International Strategic Studies Association
Reprinted with Permission.